benny.estate
For SaleMLS # B168590942 days on market

9386 State Road

Colden, NY 14033 · Erie County

Price

$449,900

Bed / Bath

2 bd · 2.5 ba

Interior

1,829 sqft

Lot

10,019 sqft lot

Built

1902

Garage

2.5-car

↓ Reduced from $469,900

About this home

One-of-a-Kind Custom Home, Former Church Beautifully Converted into a Stunning Single-Family Residence! Looking for a home with character, craftsmanship, and a story to tell? This former church has been thoughtfully transformed into a beautiful single-family home, blending timeless architecture w/ modern comfort and high-end finishes throughout. Offering 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a versatile bonus room perfect for a home office, guest room, nursery, or third bedroom, this unique property provides the space and flexibility. The spacious main level features soaring cathedral ceilings that pay tribute to the building's original design while creating an open, light-filled atmosphere that is truly breathtaking. Custom kitchen serves as the heart of the home, featuring beautiful cabinetry, solid surface countertops, a handcrafted range hood, and brand-new appliances. Then seamlessly flow into the dining and living areas, making it ideal for entertaining or everyday living. The primary suite offers a private retreat with an ensuite bath and walk in closet. The fully finished basement expands your options even further w/ a second kitchen, flexible space for entertaining, recreation, guests, or multi-generational living. Including the finished basement, this incredible home offers over 3,000 square feet of finished living space. Built for longevity and efficiency, the home features a brick exterior, steel roof, steel-sided barn-style 2.5 car garage, high-efficiency boiler system, brand-new well, and new septic system. Located in the Glenwood/Colden area and less than 15 minutes from the Village of East Aurora, you'll enjoy convenient access to restaurants, shopping, golf courses, parks, and year-round recreation, including nearby Kissing Bridge Ski Resort and Sprague Brook Park. If you've dreamed of owning something truly special, this is your opportunity. This is not just a house; it's a conversation piece, a landmark. I you were thinking of building? Be sure to check this one out first! Completely rebuilt from the studs up, this home offers the quality and feel of new construction without the wait, delays, or stress of building. Square footage measured by floor plan.

Interior features

  • Cathedral Ceilings
  • Dining Area
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Eat In Kitchen
  • Separate Formal Living Room
  • Home Office
  • Country Kitchen
  • Solid Surface Counters
  • Bedroom On Main Level
  • Main Level Primary
  • Primary Suite

Exterior features

  • Blacktop Driveway

Appliances

  • Dishwasher
  • Free Standing Range
  • Gas Water Heater
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator

Mechanical

Heating

Gas, Zoned, Baseboard, Radiant

Cooling

Zoned

Schools

District

Springville-Griffith Institute

Middle

Griffith Institute Middle

High School

Griffith Institute High

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$5,715

Financing

Cash · Conventional · FHA · VaLoan

Location

Colden, NY 14033 · Erie County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of ERA Team VP Real Estate - Arcade. Listing agent: Krystal Dern. Data last updated 7/11/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.