benny.estate
For SaleMLS # B167059271 days on market

555 Water Street

Youngstown, NY 14174 · Niagara County

Price

$1,350,000

Bed / Bath

Interior

14,776 sqft

Lot

22,499 sqft lot

Built

1950

About this home

Rare waterfront investment opportunity in the heart of Youngstown, New York! Ideally situated at the mouth of the majestic Lower Niagara River where it meets Lake Ontario, this exceptional mixed-use property offers multiple income streams in one truly breathtaking location. The offering includes 2 commercial storefronts, 2 spacious updated apartments, and 12 fully leased boat slips pre-leased for the coming year creating immediate and reliable cash flow. The boat slips generate $25,000 annually while the storefronts produce $24,000 per year with the apartments providing additional rental income. The residential component features one updated 3-bedroom apartment and one spacious 2-bedroom apartment making this a versatile and lucrative investment. Beyond the existing income, the property also includes an impressive marina operation with room for up to 12 more boat slips and approved for 60 mooring balls for sailboats and gasoline dispensing facilities. There is a public boat launch directly next door. Located adjacent to the Youngstown Yacht Club and directly across from beautiful Niagara-on-the-Lake, and a short walk to Fort Niagara State Park this one-of-a-kind property offers stunning views of the Canadian shoreline in the charming waterfront Village of Youngstown.

Mechanical

Heating

Gas, Separate Meters, Forced Air

Cooling

Separate Meters, Central Air

Schools

District

Lewiston-Porter

High School

Lewiston-Porter Senior High

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$17,305

Financing

Cash

Location

Youngstown, NY 14174 · Niagara County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of Great Lakes Real Estate Inc.. Listing agent: Bruce J Andrews. Data last updated 7/17/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.