benny.estate
For SaleMLS # B171853819 days on market

5445 Creek Road

South Wales, NY 14139 · Erie County

Price

$599,900

Bed / Bath

4 bd · 4.5 ba

Interior

6,476 sqft

Lot

4.96 ac

Built

2022

Garage

10-car

About this home

Gorgeous multi-use country property with an established small-farm infrastructure offering a combination of residential, agricultural, and potentially commercial uses. 2nd photo is a virtual rendering. Barndominium Residence, Commercial Building (church) & Livestock Barn on nearly 5 Scenic Acres with two enclosed pastures along Buffalo Creek. Barndo-Residence central A/C almost 2,000 sq ft of living space, 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths with custom cabinetry, farmhouse sink, barn doors, quartz countertops, Bluetooth Surround stereo system. Rear deck overlooks 2 enclosed pastures to the creek. Stairs lead down to an enclosed dog run. Below the residence is nearly 2,000 sq ft of heated garage space perfect for car collection, toys or shop use. The “Pass Thru” overhead doors are convenient but also frame out one of the best views in WNY! —Commercial Building (church) is 3,456 square feet exploding with potential and once was the dream of converting to main residence. Featuring a new roof (2015), blown-in insulation (2017), A/C splits, and many other improvements geared towards the maximum functionality and opportunity of this space. This flexible commercial structure includes a retail entry area, main hall, administrative offices, two bathrooms, and a lower-level commercial kitchen with production and storage areas. A double-door walkout allows for efficient shipping and receiving and a generator power connection for quick access. The space offers exceptional flexibility for creative studios, workshops, events, or potential residential conversion (subject to Town approval). Livestock Structure (barn) out back designed with hemlock distressed look is newer built and has all of the conveniences you will need to run your farm through the year with electricity, water, insulated tack room/milk house, frost-free hydrant. Stalls open to an enclosed paddock then the two electric-fenced pastures along Buffalo Creek. Additional structures include a horse/goat shed overlooking the second pasture and a front tool shed for added storage and utility. Make your dream your reality in a property designed for space, freedom, and a lifestyle defined by possibility.

Interior features

  • Eat In Kitchen
  • Other
  • See Remarks
  • Second Kitchen
  • In Law Floorplan
  • Bath In Primary Bedroom
  • Workshop

Exterior features

  • Blacktop Driveway
  • Propane Tank Leased

Appliances

  • Appliances Negotiable
  • Propane Water Heater
  • See Remarks

Mechanical

Heating

Ductless, Propane, Zoned, Forced Air

Cooling

Ductless, Zoned, Central Air

Schools

District

Iroquois

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$9,392

Financing

Cash · Conventional · UsdaLoan · VaLoan

Location

South Wales, NY 14139 · Erie County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty. Listing agent: Vincent J Ciffa. Data last updated 10/18/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.