benny.estate
For SaleMLS # B16978421 days on market

5100 Route 16

Hinsdale, NY 14743 · Cattaraugus County

Price

$385,000

Bed / Bath

3 bd · 2 ba

Interior

2,695 sqft

Lot

34.57 ac

Built

1870

Garage

1-car

About this home

Experience quiet country living on your own beautiful 30+ acre retreat in Hinsdale where privacy and convenience come together. This property offers the peaceful lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of, with room to explore, entertain, and enjoy the outdoors. Step through the double front doors into a sitting room filled with natural light from the high ceiling skylight and beautiful views of the backyard. A mini loft overlooks the space, adding character to the home’s unique design. The main level features two full bathrooms, the laundry area, and the first of three bedrooms which could also be a home office or den. The dining area highlights built-in bookshelves and a cozy fireplace open to the country kitchen featuring a large island, a new cooktop, and a new dishwasher. A living area at the back of the home provides the perfect place to relax while taking in views of the surrounding countryside. Upstairs are the other 2 bedrooms. An attached 1.5-car garage provides parking while also offering additional space for storage or a workshop. Outside is where this property truly shines. Enjoy multiple outdoor entertaining spaces, including a pergola draped in mature grapevines just off the kitchen. Wander the walking trails that wind throughout the property, passing berry bushes, pear and apple trees, and the original well house. The property’s two barns offer endless possibilities. The large barn is wired with lighting and has served as a wonderful gathering space for parties, celebrations, and special events, making it much more than just a farm building. The second barn is ideal for hobby farming, with space suited for goats, sheep, chickens, or other small livestock. A pasture completes the setup for those looking to embrace country living. Whether you’re dreaming of a hobby farm, hosting unforgettable gatherings, exploring your own wooded trails, or simply enjoying the peace and quiet of country living, this exceptional property offers a rare opportunity to own a private retreat where historic character, modern functionality, and an unmatched rural lifestyle come together. Two tax parcels included to equal 34.57 acres. Delayed negotiations-offers due 8/2 at 3pm.

Interior features

  • Den
  • Separate Formal Dining Room
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Country Kitchen
  • Kitchen Island
  • Bedroom On Main Level
  • Loft

Exterior features

  • Blacktop Driveway
  • Patio

Appliances

  • Built In Range
  • Built In Oven
  • Dishwasher
  • Electric Cooktop
  • Electric Water Heater
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator

Mechanical

Heating

Propane, Hot Water, Wood

Schools

District

Hinsdale

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$4,113

Financing

Cash · Conventional · FHA · VaLoan

Location

Hinsdale, NY 14743 · Cattaraugus County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of ERA Team VP Real Estate. Listing agent: Bobbi Jo Kent. Data last updated 7/21/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.