benny.estate
For SaleMLS # S1628614222 days on market

5 & 9 Prospect Street

Little Falls, NY 13365 · Herkimer County

Price

$499,900

Bed / Bath

2 bd · 2.5 ba

Interior

16,960 sqft

Lot

18,295 sqft lot

Built

1914

About this home

Step back in time, specifically 1914 and immerse yourself in a place of mystery and magnificence. A grand building Where we can imagine the secret meetings, voices, and music that once echoed in the halls. Step inside one of the few modern monoliths that remain standing firm...of the Masonic Lodge. Step inside one of the few modern monoliths that remain standing firm of the Masonic Lodge. Setting majestically on the corner of Prospect and School streets, in the City of Little Falls, this French Gothic Castle is striking with its back drop of the Mohawk River and the Valley hilltops. The building is constructed of brick and stone with French Medieval half timber work and cement stucco. The framing is a combination of wood and Steel beams, the latter used to support the wider spans and heavier weight loads associated with the larger rooms in the building. The main roof and roofs of the two towers are red terra cotta tile flashed with copper. Over the years the building has been utilized for other purposes including: a nursery school, pottery and art studio, dance and music practice and presentations, elegant events, and as a magnificent living space. With Over 12,000 square feet of interior space, the sky really is the limit on the elevated living spaces and, the creative and imaginative, entrepreneurial spirit of the inhabitants. The current owners have invested a significant investment into the property and taken the potential of what could be created, to a whole new level! On the main level, an incredible bar was installed with the vision of a space that can host elegant affairs. A 150 thousand dollar screen projection system was installed to offer full motion picture, professional licensed current content. Custom ballroom curtains with materials ordered from France adorn the space. A full level of the castle offers living quarters. Much of the custom kitchen is already installed. 2 bedrooms and grand, personal entertaining rooms boast soaring ceilings and magnificent views. There is an abundance of building materials on site that will convey to the next owner to complete the vision. A total of 4 parcels will convey with this extraordinary property.

Appliances

  • Electric Water Heater

Mechanical

Heating

Gas, Other, See Remarks

Cooling

Other, See Remarks

Schools

District

Little Falls

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$8,916

Financing

Cash

Location

Little Falls, NY 13365 · Herkimer County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of River Hills Properties LLC Barn. Listing agent: Robin Mongeau. Data last updated 3/16/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.