benny.estate
For SaleMLS # R16992150 days on market

44 Cayuga Street

Trumansburg, NY 14886 · Tompkins County

Price

$410,000

Bed / Bath

3 bd · 1.5 ba

Interior

1,689 sqft

Lot

20,473 sqft lot

Built

1910

Garage

1-car

About this home

Classic 3 BR, 1.5 Bath Greek Revival in the Village of Trumansburg. Built in 1830, it has a real sense of grandeur with a classic temple front portico, cornice and frieze trim. Around the corner to Gimme Coffee, Trumansburg Conservatory of Fine Arts and Main Street shops and restaurants. (Just 3 min. drive to the Trumansburg Golf Course!) Living Room has a natural flow into the open Dining-Den area. The rooms have perfect ‘golden ratio’ proportions with good flow and great natural light. Gorgeous original trim and elegant staircase. Hardwood and plank flooring. Large Eat-in Country Kitchen with bluestone counter and vintage cabinets. Two comfortable Bedrooms upstairs plus Main Level Office-Bedroom. 3-Season Sun Room – a good spot for your morning coffee and contemplation -- opens to a flagstone patio. Deep private back yard –with peonies, iris, day lilies, forsythia, coral bells and more. Custom stone bird bath and bench. Wrought iron fencing. Beautifully maintained. Updated Electric. Navien boiler. Mini-Split cooling on Main Level. Main Roof has Asphalt Roof with 50-year architectural shingles. Spray Foam R-40 Insulation in Attic and dense pack in walls. Municipal water and sewer with water softener and reverse osmosis filtration system. Vintage tile baths with new low flow toilets and new sinks. Pristine basement (no sump pump needed!) with flagstone floor, recently repointed stone foundation and insulated, sealed sill plate. Detached Garage. As soon as you walk in the front door – you’ll know this home is something special – you’ll feel the difference. It just might be THE ONE.

Interior features

  • Separate Formal Dining Room
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Eat In Kitchen
  • Separate Formal Living Room
  • Home Office
  • Country Kitchen
  • Solid Surface Counters
  • Natural Woodwork
  • Bedroom On Main Level
  • Programmable Thermostat
  • Workshop

Exterior features

  • Blacktop Driveway
  • Patio

Appliances

  • Dryer
  • Dishwasher
  • Exhaust Fan
  • Gas Oven
  • Gas Range
  • Gas Water Heater
  • Microwave
  • Refrigerator
  • Range Hood
  • Washer
  • Water Purifier Owned

Mechanical

Heating

Ductless, Gas, Heat Pump, Radiators, Steam

Cooling

Ductless, Heat Pump, Window Units

Schools

District

Trumansburg

Elementary

Trumansburg Elementary

Middle

Russell I Doig Middle

High School

Charles O Dickerson High

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$8,822

Financing

Cash · Conventional

Location

Trumansburg, NY 14886 · Tompkins County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. (Downtown). Listing agent: Laurel Guy. Data last updated 7/16/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.