benny.estate
For SaleMLS # S170687718 days on market

3909 Factory Road

Natural Bridge, NY 13665 · Lewis County

Price

$70,000

Bed / Bath

—

Interior

2,100 sqft

Lot

21,035 sqft lot

Built

1930

About this home

Some properties are measured in square feet. Others are measured in stories. Locally known as “The Silver Dollar,” this one-of-a-kind Natural Bridge property has spent generations adapting to its community, from its early days as a milk state along the neighboring railroad tracks to a dance hall, roller rink, bar, workshop and more. Today, its next chapter is waiting to be written. Step inside and you'll find an incredible amount of space, character and history. The expansive former dance hall and roller rink retains its original wood floors and now serves as a substantial workshop, with a large, shallow crawl space below providing additional storage. A former loading lean-to remains as another reminder of the building's working past. Perhaps the biggest surprise is the newly finished studio apartment, where the property's rustic history has been thoughtfully carried forward. Handmade cabinetry and details give the space its character, while a stairway crafted from a tree and its branches leads to the loft above. Even the kitchen counters have a story; they were repurposed from the floors of a local school. The building has most recently served as storage and workshop space for a contracting business and does need TLC, but for the right buyer, that's part of the opportunity. Workshop, artisan or maker's space, live/work property, private storage, creative studio, restoration project, or something entirely its own. The Silver Dollar has already lived many lives. Maybe it's time for you to give it another.

Exterior features

  • Propane Tank Leased

Mechanical

Heating

Propane, Forced Air

Schools

District

Carthage

Elementary

Carthage Elementary

Middle

Carthage Middle

High School

Carthage Senior High

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$205

Financing

Cash · Conventional

Location

Natural Bridge, NY 13665 · Lewis County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of Bridgeview Real Estate. Listing agent: Genevieve Ball. Data last updated 8/31/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.