benny.estate
For SaleMLS # R171474617 days on market

133 Pulteney Street

Geneva, NY 14456 · Ontario County

Price

$199,900

Bed / Bath

5 bd · 2 ba

Interior

2,764 sqft

Lot

6,251 sqft lot

Built

1900

About this home

Spectacular two-unit investment property offering exceptional space, timeless character, and outstanding income potential in a premier Geneva location! Ideally situated just blocks from Hobart and William Smith Colleges, vibrant downtown Geneva, and the popular restaurants, cafés, and shops along South Exchange Street, this impressive property is a rare opportunity for investors or owner-occupants. The spacious first-floor residence is filled with warmth and character, featuring gleaming hardwood floors, an entertainment-sized living room, a gracious formal dining room, and a beautifully updated kitchen with granite countertops and a large center island. Two generously sized bedrooms, a full bathroom, and convenient private laundry complete this exceptional unit. The expansive second-floor residence offers an incredible amount of living space with three spacious bedrooms, a large living room, and a formal dining room highlighted by beautiful hardwood floors. A well-designed galley kitchen, full bathroom, and dedicated private laundry room provide excellent convenience and functionality. Outside, enjoy a sprawling front porch, separate driveways, and a flat, level backyard framed by mature trees—perfect for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying the outdoors. With separate utilities, generous room sizes, desirable updates, and an unbeatable location near the colleges and downtown, this turnkey property delivers the perfect combination of character, convenience, and investment value! Projected monthly rents: First-floor unit: $1,400 Second-floor unit: $1,600 Total projected rental income: $3,000 per month or $36,000 annually Showing windows with a confirmed showing are Wednesdays from 4-5PM, Friday from 12-2PM.

Interior features

  • Natural Woodwork

Appliances

  • Gas Water Heater

Mechanical

Heating

Gas, Forced Air

Schools

District

Geneva

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$5,799

Financing

Cash · Conventional

Location

Geneva, NY 14456 · Ontario County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of Howard Hanna. Listing agent: Richard J. Testa. Data last updated 10/5/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.