benny.estate
For SaleMLS # B171733412 days on market

116 Herkimer Street

Buffalo, NY 14213 · Erie County

Price

$259,000

Bed / Bath

6 bd · 4 ba

Interior

3,699 sqft

Lot

4,500 sqft lot

Built

1900

↓ Reduced from $275,000

About this home

West Side investment gem with three good rents, accompanied by hard working tenants. This four unit property offers the kind of combination investors look for: income already in place, a value-add opportunity, and a location that puts you in the middle of some of Buffalo’s most desirable neighborhoods. Three apartments are currently rented, providing immediate rental income, while the fourth unit is vacant and ready for renovation giving the next owner an opportunity to improve the unit and potentially increase the property’s overall income. Location is a major part of the value here. Just steps from Elmwood Village and the Allentown District, this property puts tenants within easy reach of some of Buffalo’s best restaurants, coffee shops, bars, boutiques, entertainment, parks, and neighborhood amenities. That proximity helps make the property attractive to renters who want the lifestyle and walkability of Elmwood and Allentown without paying the premium associated with being directly in those neighborhoods. For an investor, that means three existing income streams today, an opportunity to create additional value tomorrow, and a location that continues to benefit from the demand surrounding two of Buffalo’s most established urban neighborhoods. Whether you're looking to expand your portfolio or take on your next value-add project, this property deserves a look.

Interior features

  • Attic

Appliances

  • Gas Water Heater

Mechanical

Heating

Gas, Forced Air

Schools

District

Buffalo

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$5,230

Financing

Cash · Conventional · RehabFinancing

Location

Buffalo, NY 14213 · Erie County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of Main Woods Real Estate. Listing agent: Daniel Demont. Data last updated 10/13/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.