For SaleMLS # S167671878 days on market

10411 & 10401 Bayshore Drive

Henderson Harbor, NY 13651 · Jefferson County

Price

$1,990,000

Bed / Bath

5 bd · 4.5 ba

Interior

4,398 sqft

Lot

10,677 sqft lot

Built

2021

Garage

4-car

↓ Reduced from $2,100,000

About this home

A rare opportunity has arrived to own a premier Lake Ontario compound on Henderson Bay. This unique package offers the best of both worlds: a state-of-the-art architectural masterpiece at 10411 Bayshore Drive and a charming, successful rental cottage immediately next door--all situated on 115' of prime waterfront. Featuring a total of 5 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and almost 4400' square feet of living space between both properties—including a 1000 sq. ft. finished basement with walk-out access to a terraced lawn & hot tub—your options are endless, from a multi-generational family estate to a luxury primary residence with a high-performing income property. Thoughtfully crafted and completed in August 2022, the custom home designed by architect Michael Aubertine redefines lakeside living. From luxury finishes to high-efficiency utilities, every inch is a testament to quality & comfort. As you move throughout the home, massive picture windows throughout focus the eye on seemingly countless lakefront vistas. Just steps away lies a classic 2-bedroom cottage that captures the nostalgic heart of Henderson Harbor. Perfectly preserved yet thoughtfully updated, modern amenities are casually woven throughout to maintain that low-key lakeside vibe. With a proven track record as a successful seasonal short-term rental, this property provides immediate utility as a guest house or a consistent revenue stream. Impeccable landscaping & stonework stitch the properties together and lead to the boathouse with loft sleeping quarters and a private dock—the ultimate spot for morning coffee or sunset photos. Both properties include additional lots with parking & storage space. Discover what other treasures are to be found at this one-of-a-kind estate, contact an agent today to schedule a private tour.

Interior features

Separate Formal Dining Room
Entrance Foyer
Eat In Kitchen
Home Office

Exterior features

Deck
Dock
Enclosed Porch
Porch
See Remarks
Propane Tank Leased

Appliances

Dishwasher
Electric Cooktop
Exhaust Fan
Electric Water Heater
Gas Oven
Gas Range
Refrigerator
Range Hood

Mechanical

Heating

Gas, Propane, Forced Air

Cooling

Central Air, Window Units

Schools

District

Belleville Henderson

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$8,380

Financing

Cash · Conventional

Virtual tour ↗

Location

Henderson Harbor, NY 13651 · Jefferson County

Open in Google Maps ↗

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of NNY Homes Inc. Listing agent: William Leepy. Data last updated 7/15/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.