benny.estate
For SaleMLS # R166976839 days on market

10 Depot Street

Wellsville, NY 14895 · Allegany County

Price

$187,000

Bed / Bath

Interior

4,153 sqft

Lot

19,166 sqft lot

Built

1911

About this home

If you have always had a vision for "The Depot" now is your opportunity. Due to unforeseen personal issues, the current owners are offering this Historic Wellsville Erie Depot building and property for sale to the public. There is a designed renovation for the building, which has been awarded grants to assist with the construction. The awarded grants are $500,000 from Restore NY and $1,228,000 from NY Forward. This money is still available to the right buyer if qualified, to allow the design project to move forward. This project also comes with property tax incentives. The Wellsville Erie Depot opened on September 19, 1911. The last train stopped at the station in 1970. The property has since remained vacant. This 4,000 sq. ft. building and .44-acre property includes the red brick road in front of the Depot and 2 red brick parking lots on each end of the building. Structurally, this building is sound. This building has a partial basement with poured concrete wall construction. The exterior is red brick and pointing and is still in very nice condition. Through the many years of neglect, this building needs a new roof, doors, windows, and sidewalks. There are also portions of the floor that will need to be replaced due to roof leaks. Some of the materials needed such as red terra cotta tiles and rafter tails could be available. This property is also available without the awarded grants, which eliminates the stipulations of how the building can be renovated. On April 23-27, 2026, or May 4-8, 2026, potential buyers will have an opportunity to walk thru the building, followed by an answer and question session. All interested parties will need to sign up and show proof of funds prior to, by contacting your realtor.

Mechanical

Heating

Other, See Remarks, None

Schools

District

Wellsville

Tax & finance

Annual taxes

$5,763

Financing

Cash

Location

Wellsville, NY 14895 · Allegany County

MLS Attribution

Listing courtesy of Middaugh Real Estate, Inc.. Listing agent: Victoria A Joyce-Middaugh. Data last updated 5/8/2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed; should be independently verified. © NYS Alliance of MLSs.